95% of the guys on that show are complete ducks and just as many are arrogant jerks.
Here is the way a golf reality show should work.
Amateurs all over the country and world say that if they had the time and money to practice every day, they could be on Tour. Let’s see them put their money where their mouths are.
You have to be an amateur with a real job, no pro or major amateur experience.
Have me on a driving range. Send people through, let me make fun of them like Simon on American Idol. After I narrow them down on the range, I watch 16-24 finalists play in foursomes and make fun of their shot making, decisions, poor techniques that they say “it works for me,” but it really doesn’t.
Narrow it down to one foursome and the low 72 hole score is the winner. That guy gets one full year of free practice and play at a nice facility, an array of entries into qualifiers and mini tour events for the next year and an entry into q-school…and instruction from me. 🙂
If nothing else, me calling them out for taking themselves too seriously and not being near as good as they think they are would be entertaining.